Case Study: New food store, Herefordshire Council


SP Broadway was instructed to undertake a concise programme of political and community consultation to support the redevelopment of an industrial site in Leominster to house a 45,000 sq ft supermarket.


There was a competing application to build a food store on another site in Leominster. Both schemes were vehemently opposed by the local Green Party, and both schemes had been refused once before. We had to do two things: demonstrate that there was real local support for a new supermarket in Leominster, and demonstrate that our client’s proposal was preferable to the competing site.


  • As soon as the revised application was submitted we wrote to Herefordshire Council Planning Committee members to let them know the changes made and extol the virtues of our client’s scheme.
  • Media monitoring of the local newspaper clearly showed there were Leominster residents who supported a new supermarket. We therefore took out a full-page advertisement in the paper and wrote an open letter to residents, setting out the key benefits of our client’s proposal and urging supporters to contact the council and make their voices heard.
  • We also made a presentation to Leominster Town Council on behalf of our client. Though it had recommended refusal of the initial application and had a substantial Green Party contingent, the town council voted to support our client’s revised proposal. It also voted to refuse the competing proposal, having supported it the first time around.
  • In the week before the committee met we drafted and sent a hard-hitting briefing letter to all Herefordshire Council Planning Committee members, demonstrating the advantages of our client’s site over the competing proposal and highlighting the support of Leominster Town Council and residents.


Both schemes were decided at the same meeting of Herefordshire Council Planning Committee in September 2014. The competing proposal was refused unanimously, while our client’s proposal was refused by the narrow margin of 10 votes to 7. We succeeded in helping to knock the competing proposal out of contention and demonstrate real support for the benefit of our client, which was encouraged enough to consider an appeal.

Case Studies

Politics of Planning

Review: Virtual Politics of Planning Roundtable with Cllr Guy Nicholson
September 27, 2023
The Homes We Need: How to deliver on Labour’s housebuilding ambition
September 22, 2023
The Liberal Democrat approach to solving the housing crisis
September 22, 2023

Politics of Planning is our weekly planning update, bringing you the news and analysis you need to plot a successful planning course though fast-changing political waters.tyu



Cllr Dr Tumi Hawkins
Cabinet Member for Planning, South Cambridgeshire Council
Online via Microsoft Teams
7.45am - 10am
October 25, 2023
Deputy Mayor Jules Pipe
Deputy Mayor, Planning, Regeneration, and Skills, London Assembly
Online via Microsoft Teams
7.45am - 10am
November 07, 2023
Cllr Elissa Swinglehurst
Cabinet Member for Environment and Portfolio Holder for Planning, Herefordshire Council
Online via Microsoft Teams
7.45am - 10am
November 21, 2023

Throughout the year we host roundtable discussions between leading politicians and key figures within the development industry.

See All Events